June 2009

Weathering the Storm

Reducing recycling costs in a bear scrap market

Article Tools

Create a Link to this Article

Photo: CP Manufacturing

By Daniel P. Duffy

Comments

“Be fearful when others are greedy, and be greedy when others are fearful.”—investor Warren Buffet.

There has never been a better to time to make capital investments in your material recovery facility. There—I’ve said it. Yes, you heard me correctly. Now is the time to acquire as much equipment and plant improvements as you possibly can. How can I possibly justify that statement when prices for scrap metal in particular and recyclable materials in general have nosedived with the recent credit crunch and the market meltdown?

Why? Because equipment prices will never again be this low and financing will never be cheaper than they are today. Demand for scrap materials has not gone away; fearful economic times have depressed demand and economic activity. But as Warren Buffet wisely pointed out, it is just such fearful times as ours that present the best buying opportunities. Those factories in China and India that have been ravenously consuming everything from copper piping to cardboard are still there. They may currently be idle, but they are not going away. When (not if but when) the economy recovers, pent-up demand will soar and those material recovery facilities (MRFs) and recycling operations that are the most efficient and most highly automated will dominate the market during the upswing.

Not only will you be doing yourself a favor by making capital investments to the greatest extent possible, but you will also be hastening the inevitable recovery. This is due to the “paradox of thrift,” the economic concept that if everyone saves more money during times of recession, then aggregate demand will fall. When this happens, it effectively lowers the total savings in the population. The paradox argues that if everyone saves, then there is a decrease in consumption, which leads to a fall in aggregate demand and thus leads to a fall in economic growth. It is only natural to want to conserve cash and limit debt during uncertain times. However, there is no other proven method of escaping a major recession than economic stimulus—by government or by private industry.

The Process
Recycling systems at MRFs that emphasize automated sorting and processing equipment are referred to by the nickname of “dirty MRFs.” They are said to perform single-stream recycling since the waste arrives at the facility in a single, unsorted stream. In contrast, MRFs whose recycling systems rely heavily on manual sorting and processing of incoming materials are usually referred to as “clean MRFs.” Their type of recycling process is referred to as multistream recycling since major types of recyclable materials are source-separated for ease of manual handling into individual wastestreams prior to delivery to the facility.

It is the former type of process, single-stream recycling, which benefits from capital investment in sorting and processing equipment and automated control systems. Yet, even here, some manual sorting is usually required and performed as an initial step to separate paper and similar products from such bulkier items in the wastestream as metals, plastic, and glass. The automated portion of the recycling process utilizes the different physical and material characteristics to perform a separating step that removes a unique material from the wastestream. Further down the line, a different process separates out another type of material, and so on, until every different type of material is extracted and separated from the single wastestream flow.

Typically, the first material to be removed is scrap metal. There are two types of scrap metal: ferrous and nonferrous. To remove ferrous metals, the entire wastestream is carried by a belt through a magnetic separator that pulls out the ferrous metals. Although overhead magnets are often used, a more convenient configuration puts the magnets under the belt. As the belt carrying the entire wastestream passes over the magnets, the ferrous metal clings to the belts while the rest of the waste falls off at a drop off point somewhat farther down the line. As the belt continues back under its rollers, the ferrous metal sticks to the belt until it is pried off by a scraper blade and falls into a collection bin.

Nonferrous metals (mostly aluminum foil and cans) are removed afterward by a similar process called an eddy-current separator. An eddy-current separator utilizes a spinning magnet with alternating polarity to induce an electrical current in the nonferrous metal. The resultant electrical current creates its own magnetic field around the piece of otherwise nonmagnetic scrap metal, which creates a repulsive force against the rotating magnetic field. The induced magnetic field is repelled by the magnetic field utilized by the eddy-current separator, and the nonferrous metal literally leaps off of the processing table or belt into an adjacent collection bin.

Nonferrous metal can be further separated by an air knife, a device that can separate light aluminum foil from heavier metal cans. The “knife” refers to sheet flows of high-velocity air blasts arranged in a parallel sequence. The force of the air blasts lifts the aluminum foil from the heavier cans. Swirling and remixing are prevented by the separation distance between the sheets of airflow. Each type of recovered metal can be compressed in a metal baler for convenient shipping and resale.

The remaining wastestream (primarily cardboard, but also including plastic, glass, paper, or wood) continues on to disc screeners that sort by both shape and size. Waste enters the screeners’ inflow bin by means of a variable-speed conveyor belt that regulates the rate of movement. By altering the speed of the belt, the operator can even out the flows of incoming waste and prevent clumping, clogging, or exceeding the machine’s operating capacity. Disc screens consist of a floor covered with rotating discs of different sizes and shapes (circular, oval, or star,) depending on the type of material being processed. The opening sizes can be adjusted to manage different types of materials. The resultant wave motion carries larger and lighter objects higher, while heavier small objects (such as glass shards) move to the lower portion of the separator and drop through holes in the screen floor.

During these various operational stages, it is inevitable that a significant fraction of the glass portion of the wastestream gets broken into shards. These shards, as well as other objects, pass through a rotating trommel. Trommels are rotating drums equipment with small holes (usually about 2 inches in diameter) in the side and directional vanes that promote gravity separation on their interior walls. Usually, the trommel’s axis of rotation is at some angle to the horizontal to facilitate the discharge of material (a horizontal axis would result in too slow of a flow through, while vertical would be too fast). In addition to sorting vanes, more complicated trommel designs utilize flights that carry the material back up to the high end of the trommel for another pass through. This process sorts large pieces of glass and cullet suitable for recycling from small pieces that become residue.

Glass pieces large enough to be recycled can be further separated by a color sorter. This optical sorting mechanism divides glass pieces by their various colors (brown, amber, green, clear, and mixed.) Glass sorters rely on light spectrophotometry that can distinguish between various colors of glass by measuring the wavelengths of the visible light reflected back at the optical sensors. Ceramic material, on the other hand, is completely removed from the glass waste, after which the glass can be sorted by color. Once finally separated, the individual colored glass shards get sent through a glass pulverizer that reduces their size and consolidates their volume for shipping and resale.

Plastic waste objects (mostly bottles and other types of containers) also go through a subsequent sorting process. Containers and cartons are separated from bottles and flattened by a plastic baler. The bottles are further separated by the various types of plastics (HDPE, PVC, PET, etc.). The various types of plastic are ground down into particles by a granulator, and then compacted by a baler prior to shipping and resale.

Meanwhile, the paper waste that was initially separated from the wastestream undergoes its own recycling process. It also can be passed through a rotating trommel to separate mixed paper products from unusable residue. The residue falls out of the small holes on the sides of the trommel’s drum while the reusable paper passes through and continues with the sorting process. After this point, manual sorting is usually required to separate out the various types of paper (glossy magazines, newsprint, office paper, etc.). Each kind of paper is fed into its own baler for compaction and binding prior to transport to resellers.

Advertisement

A type of separator often used to separate mixed paper streams (as well as other lightweight materials) is the air classifier. This can be used at the start of the process to separate out paper waste from the general wastestream and avoid manual separation. Lighter materials are separated from heavier materials by means of a high-velocity airstream induced in a stack structure by a powerful blower installed at the top that sucks air up the shaft. Waste is fed into the stack at about the mid point. Below the waste feed is an air inlet controlled by a rotating airlock. Heavy objects fall to the bottom of the stack for removal and further sorting or disposal as unusable residue. Lighter materials are sucked up to the top of the stack. Often the air-separator stack is equipped with a cyclone separator that causes the light materials to lose their velocity and settle out based on their relative density and size.

Prior to transport for resale, almost all types of recycled materials are compacted to smaller volumes and higher densities by means of compactors designed to handle each type of material. Often, the compacted mass is further bound up with string or wire to ensure structural integrity during transport. Low-density materials (cardboard, aluminum cans, newsprint) especially need compaction to reduce what would otherwise be extremely high per-ton transport costs. Compactors are electronically controlled hydraulic systems sized for a particular task and anticipated flow through quantities (tons of materials per hour). Next Page >

What Do You Think?

Post a Comment

Be the first to tell us what you think!

Post a Comment

Not a subscriber? Sign Up
 
 
*  
 




 

Get MSW Email Updates!

Get weekly news and updates through our MSW email newsletter!